Food allergy testing: broad IgE panels raise more doubts than diagnoses
At the annual meeting of the American College of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology (ACAAI), which closed on 16 November 2026 in Phoenix, a team from Yale School of Medicine showed that many clinicians keep ordering broad food allergy test panels, even though they know these panels frequently return false-positive results. The message echoes a large Australian study in infants with suspected peanut allergy: a positive test on its own is not enough to make a diagnosis.
Background: sensitisation is not the same as allergy
Blood tests for allergy measure specific IgE, the antibodies directed against a given food. Finding them means the immune system is sensitised, not that the food will necessarily cause a reaction. Many people have positive specific IgE to foods they eat without any problem, for example because of cross-reactivity with pollens or with similar proteins.
For this reason, professional societies (ACAAI, AAAAI, EAACI and the Choosing Wisely campaign) recommend testing only when the clinical history suggests an immediate, IgE-mediated reaction, and only for the suspected foods. Indiscriminate panels covering dozens of foods are discouraged: according to ACAAI guidance material, false positives can affect 50 to 90% of results.
The study presented at ACAAI
• Research from Yale School of Medicine (Nguyen and colleagues, with allergist Katelyn Wong)
• In 2024 alone, about 1,700 food allergy panels were ordered at the researchers’ institution
• The team surveyed 43 clinicians who had ordered at least one panel: mostly internists (55%) and paediatricians (27%), with a mean of 16 years in practice; 58% were physicians (MD or DO) and 40% nurse practitioners or physician assistants
The results
• 85% knew these panels produce many false positives, yet ordered them anyway
• 44% had learned about these tests only after their training
• Reasons for ordering: suspected IgE-mediated food allergy (24%), patient or family request (21%), urticaria (20%)
• For a child with eczema and a family history of food allergy, 30% of physicians and 63% of nurse practitioners and physician assistants considered a panel appropriate, although guidelines say otherwise
• The researchers propose targeted education and electronic health record alerts at the time of ordering
Confirmation from infants with suspected peanut allergy
A few days earlier, in the Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology: In Practice, Australia’s ADAPT programme (Murdoch Children’s Research Institute) reported data on 1,275 infants under 18 months of age with a reaction to peanut and a positive allergy test. In 778 of them a hospital-based oral food challenge was performed, with increasing doses of peanut under medical supervision:
• 34.8% tolerated peanut without reacting, and their allergy label was removed
• 507 infants reacted; in 61 cases the reaction was anaphylaxis, promptly treated by staff with adrenaline (epinephrine)
• a skin prick test wheal of at least 12 mm was always associated with a reaction during the challenge, whereas lower values did not reliably discriminate
The message is the same: clinical history and tests help, but in many cases confirmation requires a supervised food challenge, to be performed only in an equipped specialist setting.
What it means for testing and for patients
• The starting point remains the clinical history: which food, how soon after eating, which symptoms, whether the reaction is reproducible
• Specific IgE should be ordered selectively for the suspected foods; total IgE alone does not indicate which food a person is allergic to
• Multiplex and molecular tests (such as the ALEX test) are useful tools for allergists interpreting complex cases, not screening tests for people without symptoms
• The basophil activation test (BAT) can help in doubtful cases at specialised centres
• Food-specific IgG or IgG4 tests are not recommended for diagnosing allergy or intolerance: they mostly reflect normal exposure to food
• The reverse is also true: at ACAAI, cases of severe reactions with negative tests were presented, for example to fish collagen contained in a drink, because standard tests do not include every protein involved. A negative test does not always rule out a reaction when the history is clear
Who should take note
• Parents of children with eczema, urticaria or digestive symptoms who are offered a “test for all allergies”
• Adults who cut many foods out of their diet on the basis of a single test
• General practitioners and paediatricians who receive requests for broad panels from families
Avoiding a food without good reason has real costs: poorer diets, anxiety and, in young children, the possibility that not introducing a food may actually favour the development of an allergy.
Limitations
• The Yale study is a survey of only 43 clinicians at a single US centre, presented at a conference and not yet published in full
• Ordering habits in Italy and elsewhere may differ
• The ADAPT study involves infants already referred to an oral immunotherapy programme: the results cannot automatically be extended to other ages or other foods
• Oral food challenges carry a risk of reactions, including severe ones, and must be performed only in specialised facilities
In summary
• A positive specific IgE indicates sensitisation, not necessarily allergy
• Broad food allergy panels, ordered without suggestive symptoms, produce many false positives and unnecessarily restrictive diets
• Among infants with suspected peanut allergy, more than one in three tolerated peanut at the oral food challenge
• An accurate diagnosis rests on the clinical history, targeted testing and, when needed, a supervised food challenge in a specialist setting
Sources:
ACAAI Annual Scientific Meeting, Phoenix, 12-16 November 2026 (Nguyen M. et al., Exploring ordering clinicians’ perspectives of food allergy panels); Healio, 15 November 2026; Brettig T. et al., Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology: In Practice, 2026 (ADAPT programme); Murdoch Children’s Research Institute (EurekAlert); Healio, 6 November 2026; ACAAI, food allergy testing guidance; ACAAI, unusual anaphylaxis cases (EurekAlert)
Laboratory tests:
Rast IgE specifiche, Prist IgE totali, Alex Test, Basophil Activation Test (BAT), Phadiatop, Allergeni, Lista allergeni
Diseases, symptoms and related pages:
Intolleranze alimentari, Allergeni nascosti, Lipid Transfer Protein LTP, Alpha-Gal, allergia alla carne, Asma bronchiale, Prurito














































Discussion about this post